Gibraltar's Garrison Library: The Cupboard That Held a Neanderthal
Last checked
A siege survivor founded it in 1793, a Neanderthal skull lay forgotten in its cupboard for sixteen years, and half of what you read about it is wrong.
On 3 March 1848 a fossil skull pulled from a quarry on the north face of the Rock was laid before a meeting of the Gibraltar Scientific Society. Someone wrote a label for it. The label said this was an ancient human who had died before the universal flood of scripture. Then the skull went into a cupboard at the Gibraltar Garrison Library, and there it stayed, ignored, for sixteen years.
It was one of the first adult Neanderthal skulls ever found, eight years ahead of the discovery that gave the species its name. This is the building that kept it, and the story of how a soldier who had lived through a four year siege came to found a library, and of how much of what gets repeated about that library is not quite right.
A library imagined under fire
The Great Siege of Gibraltar ran from June 1779 to February 1783, a relentless attempt by Spain and France to starve and bombard the British garrison into surrender. It failed, but it was a grim education in isolation. Newspapers arrived late if they arrived at all, and an officer with nothing to occupy his mind had a great deal of time to fill between alarms.
One of those officers was John Drinkwater, who had joined the 72nd Regiment as an ensign at fifteen and was a captain by the time the guns stopped. He is usually described as the young captain who founded the library, which flattens the story: he arrived a boy and spent his formative years inside a siege. Crucially, he kept careful notes.
Out of those notes came A History of the Late Siege of Gibraltar, published in 1785. It became the standard account and is still a primary source. The reward was unusual. According to his own record, when Drinkwater returned to Gibraltar after rejoining the army in 1787, General Eliott, the commander who had held the Rock through the siege, publicly thanked him for the book and gave him funds to establish the Garrison Library. The man who chronicled the privation was handed the money to fix it.
Drinkwater had, during the Siege, lamented the want of a public library in Gibraltar. Then somebody gave him the money.
1793, and the ten years before anyone could read
The library was founded in 1793. You will see the precise date 31 July 1793 repeated in various places, including, until today, on this page. We have not been able to verify it in any primary or official source, and the library's own history gives only the year, so we have taken the day out rather than keep passing on a figure we cannot stand behind.
How it was funded is better documented and more interesting. Drinkwater built it by private subscription among the officer class, with each officer paying a monthly sum towards buying books, and the scheme was kick started by the Governor, General Sir Robert Boyd, who opened the subscription list with a personal gift of 100 GBP. Gibraltar's tourist board is the source for the founder's own phrase about lamenting the want of a public library, and it gives the same 1793 founding year and no day.
Then came the part nobody mentions. It took ten years before the first reading rooms actually opened. They were in premises opposite The Convent, the Governor's residence, and the opening catalogue ran to around 460 volumes. By 1799 the holdings had grown fast enough that larger premises were agreed, and a circular went round the officers setting out the plan to expand.
The building of 1800 to 1804
Work on the present building commenced in 1800 under General Charles O'Hara, Governor of Gibraltar, and was completed in 1804. It was raised on the site of an earlier governors' residence from the period of Spanish rule. The librarian at the time was Captain Fyers of the Royal Engineers, later a Major General, and his part was far larger than the job title: he was one of the original committee members, a co signatory of that 1799 circular, and the architect and driving force behind the building as it stands.
Now the correction that matters. It is widely written that the library was officially opened in 1804 by the Duke of Kent, Queen Victoria's father. What the Gibraltar Heritage Trust and the library itself actually say is that the works were completed in 1804 under the governorship of the Duke of Kent. That is a different claim, and the difference is not pedantry.
The Duke of Kent was appointed Governor of Gibraltar in March 1802 and arrived that May. On Christmas Eve 1802 the garrison mutinied, in part against his crackdown on the taverns. He put it down hard, and the Duke's record shows he was recalled to England in 1803 and barred from returning, while remaining nominally Governor, unpaid, until his death in 1820. The man was a thousand miles away. He was the Governor on paper in 1804 and almost certainly cut no ribbon here. If you are told on a tour that he opened it, that is tradition rather than evidence.
A gentleman's club born of subscription
The club like character was not an accident of decor. The library was built for and by the officers of the garrison and ran on a clear social logic. A proprietor bought his way in and then enjoyed the run of the reading rooms, the borrowing rights and, above all, the company. For a man posted to a remote fortress at the mouth of the Mediterranean, that mattered more than the books.
Step inside today and the eighteenth century intent is still legible: tall windows, generous reading rooms, ranks of bound spines. That dual function, half scholarly institution and half social club, is the key to the place. It was the drawing room of a society that had no other. It stayed a privately run institution under a Trust for more than two centuries, until September 2011, when it transferred to the Government of Gibraltar. For the wider picture of how the Rock came to be governed this way, our explainer on Gibraltar's status sets the scene.
The skull in the cupboard
Here is what lifts the Garrison Library from local landmark to scientific footnote. The skull came out of Forbes Quarry on the north face, and it was presented to the Gibraltar Scientific Society on 3 March 1848 by Lieutenant Edmund Henry Réné Flint, the Society's secretary. Sources differ on his rank and service, some calling him a Royal Navy captain, so treat the title loosely. The fossil, now catalogued as Gibraltar 1, is one of the first adult Neanderthal skulls ever found. It predates the Neander Valley discovery in Germany by eight years and Darwin's Origin of Species by eleven.
Nobody understood what they were looking at. The record of the skull is blunt: it was labelled an ancient human who died before the universal flood, and it was forgotten in a cupboard at the Garrison Library for years. The Scientific Society that held it did not last either; it was custodian from 1848 until its own demise in 1853. After the single line in the minute book recording its arrival, the next firm trace of the skull is its appearance in London in July 1864.
Then Darwin changed the question, and the answer became findable. The skull was presented at a meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science in September 1864. Darwin did not attend, but he later examined it, as did Thomas Huxley, and both concluded it belonged to an extinct human species. It is now in the Human Evolution gallery of the Natural History Museum in London, with a cast held in Gibraltar. Had it been read correctly in 1848, the science of human origins might carry a Gibraltarian name rather than a German one. Our guide to the Forbes Quarry skull tells that story in full.
For sixteen years one of the most important fossils in human history sat in a library cupboard, mislabelled as a victim of Noah's flood.
Home of the Gibraltar Chronicle
The library's intellectual life extended well beyond its shelves. It became the home and archive of the Gibraltar Chronicle, first printed in 1801, with the second edition appearing on 8 May that year and daily publication from 1821. You will often see it called the oldest English language newspaper in continuous print. The paper's record and most other accounts put it second, not first, which is still a remarkable thing for a town of this size.
Its first scoop is the one worth standing in the room for. The Chronicle carried the news of Trafalgar and the death of Nelson on 23 October 1805, two days after the battle, in English and French. The library holds a complete run of the paper from 1801, including that Trafalgar edition. The editorial offices moved out in 2006 and the print works relocated in 2007, but the archive stayed. For most of two centuries this single building was at once the reading room, the social club and the news desk of the Rock.
The gardens and the dragon tree
Outside the reading rooms lie the Garrison Library Gardens, a pocket of quiet in the middle of town, and the planting includes dragon trees, the slow growing species native to the Canary Islands. They are the sort of living antique that rewards an unhurried visitor, and they are also routinely over aged, including by us.
We previously suggested these trees might date from the period of Spanish rule, which would make them well over three hundred years old. There is no evidence for that. A survey of Gibraltar's dragon trees by the botanist John Cortes in the 1990s estimated the tallest specimens in the Garrison Library Gardens, the Botanic Gardens and The Convent at just over a hundred years, and treated that as a minimum. Precise dating is genuinely impossible: the dragon tree is a monocotyledon and lays down no annual growth rings, so age is inferred from branching points and watering throws the estimate off. The Botanic Gardens hold Gibraltar's oldest at an estimated three hundred years, but that is the Alameda, not here. Impressive trees of uncertain age is the honest description.
What is on the shelves today
The modern library works as a reference and research institution, holding around 45,000 items: books, newspapers and maps, with a great many rare and antiquarian volumes. The character of the collection still reflects its origins, rich in military history, travel narrative and the literature of empire, alongside an irreplaceable archive of Gibraltar's own story. It is less a place to borrow a paperback than a place to handle the printed memory of the Rock.
| Detail | What the record actually says |
|---|---|
| Founded | 1793, by Captain John Drinkwater. No source we can find gives a day |
| Funding | Officers' monthly subscriptions, opened by Governor Sir Robert Boyd with 100 GBP |
| First reading rooms | About ten years after founding, opposite The Convent, around 460 volumes |
| Present building | Begun 1800 under Governor Charles O'Hara, completed 1804 |
| Architect | Captain Fyers of the Royal Engineers, also the librarian of the day |
| The Duke of Kent | Nominally Governor in 1804, but recalled from Gibraltar in 1803 and barred from return |
| Founder's name | John Drinkwater at the founding. Bethune added after his wife inherited in 1837 |
| Collection | Around 45,000 items including books, newspapers and maps |
| Famous resident object | The Forbes Quarry Neanderthal skull, forgotten in a cupboard from 1848 |
| Newspaper link | Home and archive of the Gibraltar Chronicle, printed since 1801 |
| Transferred to government | September 2011, after two centuries under a private Trust |
Fitting it into a slow culture day
The Garrison Library suits the traveller who would rather linger over one extraordinary room than tick off ten attractions. Build a morning around the old town: walk up from Grand Casemates Square, take a quiet hour in the library and its gardens, then weave through the lanes around it. Pair it with a long lunch, perhaps drawn from our food and drink guide to Gibraltar. If your stay is short, our 48 hours in Gibraltar itinerary shows how to thread culture between the headline sights.
One practical word, and we will not pretend to precision we do not have. This is a working research institution rather than a museum, access is not the same as walking in off the street, and guided tours are arranged rather than running on a fixed timetable. We are not going to print opening hours that may have changed by the time you read this. Contact the library before you go, and aim for a weekday morning when the rooms are quiet, which is how the place is best met.
Plan your visit to the Garrison Library
If a morning of antiquarian shelves, dragon trees of debatable age and the cupboard that once hid a Neanderthal sounds like your kind of Gibraltar, base yourself somewhere that makes slow days easy. Victory Suites sits on Devils Tower Road, about a ten minute walk from Grand Casemates Square, which puts the old town and the library a gentle stroll from the door, and minutes from Gibraltar International Airport when you arrive and leave. Our 100+ serviced apartments come with full kitchens, so you can cook after an unhurried afternoon, with an indoor pool and gym on site for the hours you are not exploring. Our team knows the rhythm of the old town and can help you time a visit for when the reading rooms are calm.
Frequently asked questions
Who founded the Gibraltar Garrison Library, and when?
Captain John Drinkwater, the historian of the Great Siege, founded it in 1793. He had joined the 72nd Regiment as an ensign at fifteen and was a captain by the end of the siege. General Eliott, who commanded the Rock through the siege, publicly thanked him for his history of it and gave him funds to start the library. Many sources give a precise date of 31 July 1793, but we have not found that day confirmed in any official or primary record, so we cite only the year.
Did the Duke of Kent really open the Garrison Library in 1804?
Almost certainly not in person, despite the claim being repeated widely. The library's own history and the Gibraltar Heritage Trust say the building was completed in 1804 under the governorship of the Duke of Kent, which is not the same as being opened by him. He was appointed Governor in March 1802, the garrison mutinied on Christmas Eve that year, and he was recalled to England in 1803 and barred from returning, though he stayed nominally Governor until his death in 1820. He was not in Gibraltar in 1804.
Was a Neanderthal skull really kept in a cupboard there?
Yes. The Forbes Quarry skull, now catalogued as Gibraltar 1, was presented to the Gibraltar Scientific Society on 3 March 1848 by its secretary, Lieutenant Edmund Henry Réné Flint. It was labelled as an ancient human who died before the universal flood and then forgotten in a cupboard at the Garrison Library. Its next firm trace is its arrival in London in July 1864, after which it was presented to the British Association for the Advancement of Science that September. Darwin and Huxley both later examined it.
Why did nobody realise what the skull was in 1848?
Because the framework for understanding it did not exist yet. The skull predates the Neander Valley discovery in Germany by eight years and Darwin's Origin of Species by eleven, so in 1848 there was no accepted idea of an extinct human species to assign it to. Biblical chronology was the available explanation, which is why the label described a victim of the flood. Only after Darwin reframed the question did anyone go looking in the cupboard.
How old are the dragon trees in the Garrison Library Gardens?
Nobody can say precisely, and claims that they date from the Spanish period before 1704 are unsupported. A survey of Gibraltar's dragon trees in the 1990s put the tallest specimens in the Garrison Library Gardens, the Botanic Gardens and The Convent at just over a hundred years as a minimum estimate. The species is a monocotyledon and produces no annual growth rings, so age has to be inferred from branching points, and watered garden trees skew the method.
Is the Gibraltar Chronicle the world's oldest English language newspaper?
It is usually described as the second oldest in continuous print, not the first. It was first printed in 1801, with the second edition on 8 May that year, and has been a daily since 1821. Its great scoop was carrying the news of Trafalgar and Nelson's death on 23 October 1805, two days after the battle, in English and French. The Garrison Library holds a complete run from 1801, including that edition.
Can visitors go inside the Garrison Library?
It is a working reference and research institution rather than a museum, so access is not simply a matter of walking in, and guided tours are arranged rather than running to a fixed timetable. Contact the library directly before your visit to confirm current arrangements. A weekday morning tends to be the quietest time, which is when the reading rooms show themselves best.